Why Email Marketing is More Crucial Than Ever in the Wake of Potential Social Media Bans

The possibility of TikTok being banned in the United States has sent shockwaves through the business community. For many brands, social media platforms like TikTok have been invaluable for driving engagement, building audiences, and generating sales. However, this potential ban underscores a harsh reality for businesses: platforms you don’t own can be taken away overnight. TikTok possibly being banned, brands getting blocked or their accounts removed entirely due to content not aligning with the platform puts businesses and marketers in a difficult position. This raises a critical question—what’s your fallback plan if social media disappears?

Enter email marketing. Email marketing is your business’s most reliable relationship-building channel while it should not replace social media—which remains a vital tool for grabbing attention and building initial awareness. In this blog, we’ll explore why email marketing is indispensable in today’s landscape and how businesses can reposition their strategies to place email at the core of their digital efforts.

The Fragility of Social Media Dependence

The TikTok scenario isn’t an isolated incident. Platforms like Facebook, Instagram, and Twitter have all faced outages, regulatory scrutiny, and algorithm changes that leave businesses scrambling. Here’s why over-relying on social media is risky:

1. You Don’t Own the Platform: When you build an audience on social media, it’s akin to renting space. Algorithms change, accounts get suspended, and in extreme cases, platforms can be banned.

2. Unpredictable Algorithms: Social media platforms constantly tweak their algorithms, often deprioritizing organic reach in favor of paid promotions.

3. Regulatory Risks: Social media companies are under increasing scrutiny from governments worldwide, which can result in sudden bans, restrictions, or operational changes.

These uncertainties make it imperative for businesses to shift their perspective on social media. Rather than treating it as a core asset, consider it a top-of-funnel tool for capturing attention and directing traffic to more reliable channels—like email.

Why Email Marketing is a Core Asset

Unlike social media, email marketing is a platform you own and control. When you collect email addresses, you’re building an asset that can’t be taken away by external forces. Here’s why email is indispensable:

1. Direct Communication: Emails land directly in your subscribers’ inboxes, free from algorithmic interference. Most companies with good reputations see an email delivery rate of 99% while a social post gets seen by less than 30% of followers if it’s not promoted.

2. Higher ROI: According to studies, email marketing delivers an average ROI of $42 for every dollar spent, making it one of the most cost-effective marketing channels.

3. Personalization: Advanced segmentation and automation tools allow you to deliver highly personalized content tailored to your audience’s preferences and behaviors.

4. Longevity: Email lists are enduring assets. While platforms may come and go, email remains a constant in digital communication.

5. Two-Way Relationship Building: Email fosters a deeper connection, allowing businesses to engage with their audience through exclusive offers, updates, and personalized messages.

How to Reposition Email Marketing as a Relationship Builder

Repositioning email marketing from a secondary tool to a primary relationship builder requires a shift in mindset and strategy. Here are key steps to make email the cornerstone of your marketing efforts:

1. Focus on List Building

Your email list is your most valuable digital asset. Treat it as such by implementing robust strategies to grow your list:

• Lead Magnets: Offer free resources like eBooks, webinars, or discounts in exchange for email addresses. When creating these assets, ensure you are creating something of value to your potential customers. Many brands create a half-banked PDF and complain when they don’t see results.

• Opt-in Forms: Place sign-up forms prominently on your website, blog, and landing pages. Test as much as you can.

• Social Media Integration: Use your social channels to drive email sign-ups with compelling CTAs. Don’t just push people to your home page. Create unique experiences that cross over from your social platforms into your website and email list. 

2. Create a Welcome Series

A strong first impression sets the tone for your relationship with subscribers. A well-crafted welcome email sequence should:

• Thank them for joining.

• Introduce your brand story, values, and offerings. Don’t overdue it on the first email though, keep it short and sweet so your subscriber can get back to their business with your help. 

• Offer an exclusive discount or resource to build goodwill. A discount allows the subscriber to go back to shopping. A good resource should be a guide they can quickly follow as they complete the task they have at hand. Don’t make your new subscriber jump through too many hoops. 

3. Leverage Personalization and Segmentation

Generic emails are a thing of the past. Use segmentation to group subscribers based on:

• Purchase behavior

• Browsing history

• Interests

• Demographics

• Recent Activity/Inactivity

Personalization can go beyond using first names—recommend products, share tailored content, or send event reminders based on their location. WIth email, you can create unique experiences that match each subscriber’s situation. 

4. Incorporate Automation

Automation ensures you stay connected with your audience without manual effort. Popular automations include:

• Abandoned Cart Emails: Recover lost sales by reminding customers about items left in their carts. Avoid being too big brother. Add value with every touch point. Instead of a simple, “You left these items in your cart”. Try to adapt to the reasons why they left the items in their cart. (Eg. “You almost completed your order… Do you need approval from someone? We can help you here is a quick doc that outlines our benefits”)

• Post-Purchase Sequences: Build loyalty by thanking customers and sharing care instructions or complementary product recommendations.

• Win-Back Campaigns: Re-engage inactive subscribers with exclusive offers or new arrivals.

5. Prioritize Value Over Promotion

Email should not just be a sales channel. Build trust and engagement by sharing:

• Educational content (e.g., how-to guides, industry insights)

• Behind-the-scenes updates

• Community stories or testimonials

• Exclusive offers or early access to products

Remember email doesn’t sell! People can’t put a credit card in an email. Email is the assistant to a sale. It can guide your subscribers on how to buy, where to buy and remove any friction with education. 

Social Media + Email: A Powerful Duo

While email marketing is a core relationship builder, social media still plays an important role in your overall strategy. Here’s how to use them together effectively:

1. Use Social Media to Drive Email Sign-Ups: Promote your email list on social platforms by highlighting the exclusive benefits of subscribing.

2. Share Email Content on Social Media: Repurpose valuable email content, like tips or promotions, for your social channels.

3. Retarget Email Subscribers: Use email data to create custom audiences for paid ads on social media platforms, ensuring a cohesive multi-channel experience.

Not Sure Where to Start?

You landed at the right place! We help businesses grow by helping them reposition email marketing with their other marketing efforts. Click below to reach out.